Jefferson County
C
Overall14.7kPopulation

Photo: Wikipedia

Quality of Life

Overall Quality Of Life
C+
Average

A livable area that tracks near national norms for affordability, walkability, and neighborhood health.

What does this tell us?

Quality of Life measures an area by evaluating factors like cost of living, nearby amenities, country club access, airport proximity, socioeconomic signals and neighborhood character. For large states, this is a general average — quality of life can vary dramatically between metro areas, suburbs, and rural communities within the same state.

Cost of Living

69/100

31% below national average

A+
Affordability Ratio

100%

The Real Cost of Living in Jefferson County

TierIndividualFamily (4)
Survival $13k$24k
Comfortable $39k$57k
Luxury $100k+$156k+
Elite (Top 5%) $118k+$183k+

Quality-of-Life Analysis

Jefferson County, Florida, offers a spectrum of quality-of-life options ranging from the historic, walkable streets of its county seat, Monticello, to the deeply rural, agricultural hamlets like Wacissa and Aucilla. With a cost of living index of 69—well below the national average of 100—the county primarily attracts retirees seeking quiet, land-based living, along with commuters who work in Tallahassee (about 30 minutes north) and value space over urban amenities. The county’s character shifts noticeably from the concentrated services of its largest town to the sparse, nature-oriented pockets of its unincorporated communities.

Largest town(s) & population centers

Monticello is the county’s sole incorporated city and its undisputed population and commercial center, home to roughly 2,500 residents. Daily life here revolves around the historic downtown square, anchored by the Jefferson County Courthouse, local restaurants like The Grateful Plate, and independent shops. The town offers essential services—a grocery store, a hardware store, a public library, and a hospital (Doctor’s Memorial Hospital)—but lacks the big-box retail or entertainment options found in Tallahassee. Many residents commute north for work, reflected in the county’s average commute time of 29.4 minutes, which is notably longer than the national average of 26.4 minutes. Monticello provides a compact, walkable core for those who want a small-town feel with a recognizable downtown, while the surrounding subdivisions and acreage cater to families wanting more land without being fully isolated.

Smaller towns & rural pockets

Beyond Monticello, Jefferson County is defined by unincorporated communities that are little more than crossroads or historic settlements. Wacissa, located along the Wacissa River, is a tiny, unincorporated hamlet known for its spring-fed river and canoe launches; it has no grocery store or gas station, and residents rely on Monticello or Tallahassee for all errands. Aucilla, straddling the Jefferson-Madison county line near the Aucilla River, is similarly sparse, with a handful of homes and a post office but no commercial core. Lamont, further south along US-19, is a rural crossroads with a few churches and a volunteer fire department. These areas offer the lowest density in the county, with homes often set on 5- to 20-acre tracts, and appeal strongly to hunters, equestrians, and those seeking complete seclusion. The median home value of $198,800 and median rent of $790 make even these remote properties affordable compared to state or national averages.

Cost & lifestyle range

The cost and lifestyle spread across Jefferson County is wide but predictable. At the higher end, Monticello’s historic district features restored antebellum homes and newer subdivisions like Woodland Hills, where home prices can reach $300,000–$400,000, though still well below Florida coastal markets. These areas offer sidewalks, proximity to the town square, and shorter commutes to Tallahassee. At the lower end, rural tracts near Wacissa or along US-19 south of Monticello can be found for under $150,000, especially for older mobile homes or fixer-uppers on acreage. Renters in these areas are rare, as the rental stock is almost entirely in Monticello itself; the $790 median rent reflects the town’s modest apartment complexes and duplexes. Amenities thin out dramatically outside Monticello: there is no public transit, no ride-sharing presence, and the nearest Walmart or chain grocery is in Tallahassee. The trade-off is direct access to the Wacissa River, Aucilla Wildlife Management Area, and the St. Marks National Wildlife Refuge, offering world-class paddling, fishing, and birding.

Jefferson County is best suited for people who prioritize low cost, space, and quiet over convenience and career density. Retirees on fixed incomes, remote workers who can tolerate a 30-minute commute for shopping and dining, and outdoor enthusiasts who want immediate access to rivers and forests will find the county’s range of options—from Monticello’s walkable historic core to Wacissa’s riverfront solitude—highly livable. Those needing frequent urban amenities, diverse employment, or a robust rental market will likely find the trade-offs too steep.

Powered byGrok

Crime

Overall Crime Grade
B+
Safe

Generally safer than 68% of comparable U.S. locations.

Crime Rate
11.2
Incidents per 1,000 residents
5yr Trend
+123.5%
Overall crime change since 2020

Violent Crime

5yr+119.5%
Homicide
0.03 / 1k ResidentsEqual to state avg
Robbery
0.28 / 1k Residents1% above state avg
Aggravated Assault
1.57 / 1k Residents1% above state avg

Property Crime

5yr+127.4%
Burglary
1.02 / 1k Residents1% above state avg
Larceny-Theft
7.50 / 1k Residents1% above state avg
Motor Vehicle Theft
0.56 / 1k Residents1% above state avg
Source: FBI Crime Data · 2025

Crime Analysis

Jefferson County, Florida, presents a mixed safety picture: its violent crime rate of 210.1 per 100,000 residents is notably lower than both the Florida state average (roughly 380 per 100K) and the national median, while its property crime rate of 910.4 per 100,000 sits slightly above the state average of about 850 per 100K. The county’s rural character and small population (roughly 15,000) mean that crime statistics can fluctuate significantly year-to-year, but the overall trend suggests a community where violent incidents are uncommon, though property crimes like theft and burglary remain a persistent concern for residents in unincorporated areas and the county’s two main towns.

Crime in context

Jefferson County’s violent crime rate of 210.1 per 100,000 is roughly 45% lower than the Florida state average and about 40% lower than the national median, placing it among the safer rural counties in the Big Bend region. By contrast, the property crime rate of 910.4 per 100,000 is 7% above the state average and roughly on par with the national median. For context, neighboring Leon County (home to Tallahassee) reports a violent crime rate near 500 per 100K and a property crime rate above 2,500 per 100K, making Jefferson County significantly safer than its urban neighbor. However, the county’s proximity to Tallahassee—a large, liberal-leaning metro area with progressive district attorneys and judicial policies—does introduce some spillover crime, particularly property theft and drug-related offenses from individuals traveling into Jefferson County’s more rural areas.

What residents experience

Residents in the county seat of Monticello (population ~2,500) report that violent crime is rare, with most incidents involving domestic disputes or isolated assaults rather than random street violence. The town’s small police department maintains a visible presence, and community watch programs are active in neighborhoods like the historic district and around the courthouse square. In the smaller community of Wacissa, property crimes—especially burglaries of unoccupied homes and farm equipment theft—are the primary safety concern, driven by the area’s rural isolation and limited sheriff’s patrol coverage. The unincorporated areas along U.S. Highway 19 and State Road 59 see higher rates of vehicle break-ins and theft from construction sites, particularly near the county line with Madison County. Residents in Lamont and Ashville often cite the lack of street lighting and long response times from the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office as factors that increase their sense of vulnerability, though actual violent incidents remain infrequent.

Neighborhood-level variation

Safety in Jefferson County varies noticeably by location. The town of Monticello itself is generally considered the safest area, with a concentrated law enforcement presence and a tight-knit community where neighbors watch out for one another. The historic district and newer subdivisions near the Jefferson County High School report the lowest crime rates in the county. In contrast, the rural corridor along U.S. 19 south of Monticello toward the Taylor County line experiences more property crime, including theft from vehicles and occasional burglaries of vacation homes. The Aucilla River area and the remote communities near the Florida-Georgia line see the least law enforcement coverage, and residents there should take extra precautions—such as installing security systems and forming neighborhood watch groups—to mitigate the risk of property crime. Overall, Jefferson County offers a relatively safe environment compared to Florida’s urban centers, but the influence of progressive criminal justice policies in nearby Tallahassee means that property crime and drug-related offenses remain a concern that residents should not ignore.

Powered byGrok

* Values derived from national, state, county, city and local statistics and may differ in a specific area. Last updated: 2026-11-14T05:11:27.000Z

Narrative content on this page is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. Verify any details that matter before acting on them.

ReloMaps may earn a commission from affiliate links at no extra cost to you.

Jefferson County, FL