Photo: Wikipedia
Political ClimatePolitical Climate in Story County
Showing district-level results — no local-only data available.
Local Political AnalysisPolitical Analysis of Story County
Story County, Iowa, is a classic case of a deep-red rural area being dragged leftward by a fast-growing college town, and it’s a shift that’s been happening right under our noses. The county’s Cook PVI of R+15 tells you the old story—this place used to be rock-solid Republican territory, and outside of Ames, it still mostly is. But that number is getting softer every election cycle, and it’s a direct result of the progressive tide coming out of Iowa State University and the state government’s growing willingness to let local control slip away. If you’ve lived here as long as I have, you’ve watched the political center of gravity move from the farm fields and small towns to the campus, and it’s not a change that sits well with folks who value their personal freedoms and a government that stays out of their lives.
How it compares
When you stack Story County against the rest of Iowa, the contrast is stark. The state as a whole has a Cook PVI of R+6, meaning it leans Republican but still has a decent number of swing voters. Story County’s R+15 should, on paper, make it one of the reddest counties in the state—and it is, if you look at the rural precincts. Towns like Nevada, Story City, and Gilbert still vote reliably conservative, with precincts regularly going 60-70% for Republican candidates. But then you’ve got Ames, which is a whole different animal. The precincts around Iowa State University, especially those near campus and in the older neighborhoods like Old Town and College Creek, are now solidly blue, often flipping 55-65% Democratic. The swing precincts are the ones just outside Ames—places like Huxley and Kelley—where you see a mix of longtime residents and new commuters. Those areas are trending left, but they’re still competitive. The real concern is that the state’s overall R+6 is being propped up by rural counties like ours, while the progressive strongholds in Johnson and Story counties are pulling the state’s political center of gravity in a direction that feels increasingly out of step with the values of most Iowans.
What this means for residents
For those of us who live here, the political divide isn’t just about who you vote for—it’s about how much the government is willing to stick its nose into your daily life. In the rural parts of Story County, people still expect a hands-off approach: low taxes, minimal regulations, and the freedom to run your farm or your small business without a stack of permits. But as Ames grows, you’re seeing more pressure for progressive policies—things like higher property taxes for “sustainability” initiatives, zoning rules that make it harder to build a new shop on your own land, and a school board that’s more focused on social engineering than on teaching kids to read and do math. The state government in Des Moines has pushed back on some of this, like with the 2021 law limiting how schools can teach about race and gender, but the fight is far from over. The long-term trend is worrying: if the progressive machine in Ames keeps growing, it could eventually flip the county’s PVI, and then you’d have a situation where the rural majority is outvoted by a college town that doesn’t share their values. That’s a recipe for government overreach, plain and simple.
One of the biggest cultural distinctions you’ll notice is how differently people talk about “community” depending on where you are. In the small towns, community means neighbors helping neighbors without a government program—it’s the volunteer fire department, the church potluck, the guy down the road who plows your driveway for free. In Ames, community increasingly means organizing around political causes, with city council meetings turning into debates over housing density and bike lanes. The policy differences are real, too: Story County’s rural areas have fought hard to keep gun rights intact, while Ames has toyed with local ordinances that would restrict them. Property taxes are another flashpoint—rural residents pay for services they rarely use, like bus systems and parks, while seeing little return. If you’re considering a move here, just know that where you choose to live within Story County will determine how much government you have to deal with. Stick to the small towns if you want to keep your freedoms; Ames is a place where the government’s hand is getting heavier every year.
State Political ClimatePolitical Climate in Iowa
State Political AnalysisPolitical Environment in the State
Iowa has shifted from a classic purple swing state to a solidly Republican-leaning one, carrying a Cook PVI of R+6 and delivering double-digit victories for Donald Trump in both 2016 and 2020. The state’s political transformation over the past 15 years has been driven by a powerful realignment of its rural and small-town voters, who have moved decisively toward the GOP, while its urban centers have become increasingly Democratic strongholds. For a conservative considering relocation, Iowa offers a policy environment that has consistently prioritized limited government, parental rights, and economic freedom, though recent demographic shifts in its largest cities warrant a close look.
Urban vs. rural divide
The political map of Iowa is a study in stark contrasts. The state’s two major metros—Des Moines and Iowa City—anchor the Democratic vote, with Polk County (Des Moines) and Johnson County (Iowa City) regularly delivering margins of 15-25 points for Democratic candidates. Iowa City, home to the University of Iowa, is the state’s most progressive enclave, where local politics often mirror coastal liberal trends. Meanwhile, the rural and exurban counties that surround these metros have swung hard to the right. For example, Dallas County, just west of Des Moines, flipped from blue to red in the 2010s and now votes Republican by double digits, driven by an influx of conservative-leaning families seeking affordable land and lower taxes. The Sioux City and Council Bluffs areas in western Iowa are reliably red, while the northeastern corner around Dubuque remains a competitive battleground, with its mix of manufacturing workers and Catholic voters. The real story, though, is the collapse of Democratic support in small towns like Oskaloosa and Newton, where Obama won in 2008 but Trump carried by 20+ points in 2020—a shift that cemented Iowa’s current partisan lean.
Policy environment
Iowa’s policy landscape is a clear win for conservatives who value limited government and local control. The state has a flat income tax rate of 3.8% (phasing down to 3.5% by 2027), no inheritance tax, and property taxes that are among the lowest in the Midwest. Governor Kim Reynolds signed a major tax reform package in 2022 that accelerated rate cuts and simplified the code, making Iowa more competitive with no-income-tax states like South Dakota. On education, Iowa passed a universal school choice program in 2023, allowing any family to use state funds for private or homeschool expenses—a landmark victory for parental rights. The state also enacted a law banning transgender athletes from girls’ sports and requiring parental notification for any school health services, reflecting a strong pushback against progressive education policies. In healthcare, Iowa expanded Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act but has since pursued a waiver program that emphasizes private-market solutions and work requirements for able-bodied adults. Election integrity is a priority: Iowa requires voter ID, limits early voting to 20 days, and closed most satellite voting locations, measures that have drawn criticism from the left but are popular among conservatives who want secure elections. The state also passed a “stand your ground” self-defense law in 2017 and has constitutional carry for firearms, meaning no permit is needed to carry a concealed weapon.
Trajectory & freedom
Iowa is moving in a direction that expands personal liberty for conservatives, particularly on gun rights, parental authority, and economic freedom. The 2021 “Parental Rights in Education” law (HF 2416) requires schools to notify parents of any changes in a student’s mental, emotional, or physical health, effectively blocking “don’t say gay” style policies from the left. In 2023, the state passed a law banning abortion after a heartbeat is detected (around six weeks), which was upheld by the Iowa Supreme Court in 2024—making Iowa one of the most pro-life states in the nation. On property rights, Iowa has a strong “right to farm” constitutional amendment protecting agricultural operations from nuisance lawsuits, a critical issue for rural landowners. However, there are areas where government overreach is a concern: the state’s strict alcohol control laws (state-run liquor stores) and its relatively high cigarette taxes (over $1.30 per pack) are remnants of a more paternalistic era. The trend, though, is toward deregulation—the 2023 law allowing Sunday liquor sales and the expansion of craft breweries are signs of a loosening grip. For a new resident, the trajectory is clear: Iowa is becoming more aligned with conservative values on the issues that matter most, from school choice to gun rights.
Civil unrest & political movements
Iowa has not seen the kind of violent civil unrest that has plagued coastal cities, but it has had its share of political flashpoints. The 2020 Black Lives Matter protests in Des Moines and Iowa City were largely peaceful, though there were isolated incidents of property damage and clashes with counter-protesters. The state’s immigrant communities, particularly in Storm Lake and Postville (home to large meatpacking plants), have been at the center of immigration politics. Storm Lake, a Democratic-leaning town in a red county, has a sanctuary city ordinance that limits local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement—a policy that has drawn sharp criticism from state Republicans. In 2024, Governor Reynolds signed a law requiring local law enforcement to cooperate with ICE, effectively nullifying sanctuary policies. On the right, the “Iowa Firearms Coalition” is a powerful grassroots force that has successfully lobbied for constitutional carry and stand-your-ground laws. The state also saw a surge in “Moms for Liberty” chapters after COVID-era school closures, which helped drive the school choice movement. Election integrity remains a hot-button issue: the 2020 election in Iowa was smooth, but the 2022 law tightening voting rules was a direct response to concerns about mail-in ballot fraud. A new resident would notice that political activism here is more about school board meetings and county fairs than street protests—a sign of a healthy, engaged citizenry.
Projection
Over the next 5-10 years, Iowa is likely to become even more Republican, driven by two key trends: the continued exodus of young liberals from rural areas to Des Moines and Iowa City, and the in-migration of conservatives from high-tax states like Illinois and California. The Des Moines metro is growing, but its suburbs—like Waukee and Ankeny—are trending red as families seek good schools and low crime. The state’s population is aging, and older voters tend to be more conservative, which will further entrench the GOP’s advantage. However, there is a wild card: the University of Iowa and Iowa State University continue to attract progressive faculty and students, and if these institutions expand, they could turn Johnson and Story counties into permanent blue islands. The state’s agricultural economy is also vulnerable to trade disruptions and climate policy, which could shift rural voters if they feel abandoned by the GOP on trade. For now, the projection is for a stable R+6 to R+8 lean, with the state remaining a reliable Republican vote in presidential elections but still competitive in down-ballot races (the 2024 Senate race was a 10-point GOP win).
For a conservative moving to Iowa, the bottom line is this: you will find a state that respects your gun rights, protects your parental authority, and keeps taxes low. The urban centers are liberal, but they are small and contained—you can easily live in a red suburb or rural area and never feel the progressive pressure. The political climate is stable, the policy environment is favorable, and the trajectory is toward more freedom, not less. Just be aware that the culture war is real here, especially in school districts and county commissions, so getting involved locally is the best way to protect the values you’re moving here for.
* Values derived from national, state, county, city and local statistics and may differ in a specific area. Last updated: 2026-05-20T11:39:32.000Z
Narrative content on this page is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. Verify any details that matter before acting on them.
ReloMaps may earn a commission from affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
